Using Ductal Lavage to Stratify Risk
     
This year-long series on breast health from the Breast Cancer
Surgery Center started with breast cancer risk assessment, continued
with risk reduction, and most recently covered genetic testing. This
issue's article deals with the promising new technique entitled nipple
aspiration and ductal lavage (NADL). This new, but not experimental,
technique shows promise for further characterizing women's risks so
that selective screening can become even more precise.
     
As most women know, most abnormalities that are palpated
(felt) in a breast, or seen on a mammographic study, are not cancer.
Frequently, these lesions require removal. In the study of the cells
under the microscope, other cells are sometimes seen which can be
correlated with the patient's known riskfactors. One of the
incidental benign findings which has shown a high association with
the future development of breast cancer is termed atypical ductal
hyperplasia.
     
Most (but not all) breast cancers arise in the tubes which
carry milk from the glands to the nipple (6 - 8 ducts per nipple).
These tubes are lined with tissue termed ductal epithelium which is
usually one cell layer thick. Frequently, a portion of this ductal
lining becomes much more cellular.This is termed benign ductal
hyperplasia. Under influences which we are only now beginning to
understand, these hyperplastic areas can then develop pre-cancerous
cells. This is termed dysplasia. Dysplastic cells are just one step
away from being cancerous.
     
Since these changes do not create images on your mammogram or
lumps in your breast, they are usually found only incidental to a
second pathological process which led to a biopsy whereby these cells
are identified under the microscope. Studies have shown, quite
consistently, that women who have atypical ductal hyperplasia carry
a significantly elevated risk (over 15% in some studies)of developing
breast cancer within the next five years.
     
Even when a woman is not lactating and nursing, small amounts
of watery fluid are continuously produced in the breast. This fluid
evaporates at the nipple just like sweat and is not noticeable. When
hyperplasia, or other pathologic entities, create a narrowing, but not
a total blockage, of the duct, this fluid collects or "pools" in the
duct behind the blockage. Using a very gentle suction cup, pooled
fluid can be brought to the surface identifying that duct's opening in
the nipple. This is called nipple aspiration and the fluid is called
nipple aspiration fluid (NAF).
     
Early attempts to obtain these cells for diagnosis were
performed by blindly aspirating tissue from the four quadrants of the
breast. As you can surmise, this was not very often fruitful. Since
the duct is accessible to the outside world through its natural
opening in the nipple, technology has enabled surgeons to place a
small (0.007 in.) catheter through the natural duct opening in the
anesthetized nipple (a nearly pain-free procedure). Sterile saline
(saltwater) is gently washed through the duct obtaining thousands of
cells for microscopic examination.
     
The accuracy of this test is significantly better than the
examination of fluid which simply presents at the nipple surface.
Smears of this fluid from the nipple generally provide 10 to 30 cells
for microscopic exam (cytology). Ductal lavage specimens routinely
retrieve 800 to 1000 cells for examination. This gives a nearly 100%
accuracy in identifying the cell types present.
     
Women who by standard criteria are considered high risk are
candidates for ductal lavage. This includes (1) women who have had a
cancer in the opposite breast, (2) women with a strong family history
of breast cancer, (3) women who have a high Gail Model risk, and (4)
women whose genetic testing has shown them to have a deleterious
mutation. When these women are shown, by NADL, to have atypical
ductalhyperplasia, additional risk reduction methods can be employed
to either reduce the chance of developing cancer, or increase the
chance of finding it at its earliest possible (curable) stage.
     
Ductal lavage can, on occasion, diagnose breast cancer
cells themselves. This is usually two to three years before
any changes become apparent on the mammogram. Women who are found
to have cancer at this stage are usually 100% curable.
Furthermore, they frequently do not need either chemotherapy or
radiation therapy to achieve this excellent outcome.
     
The latest studies on ductal lavage show additional information
which may become useful. Surgeons have studied the types and amounts
of protein in the ductal lavage fluid. Over 1500 separate proteins
have been identified in ductal fluid. Studies have shown that women
who have a cancer in one breast do not have significantly different
ductal proteins in the opposite breast.
     
However, women who have had a cancer in either breast have a
significantly different protein composition from those women who do not
have cancer. This may, in the very near future, provide another tool
for identifying women who are likely to develop cancer within the next
6 to 18 months and enable them to employ additional therapy plans to
achieve the results outlined several paragraphs above (prevention or cure!)
     
Approximately 200 surgeons across the United States have been
credentialed to perform nipple aspiration and ductal lavage. Since most
insurance companies do not cover this procedure, it has not been as widely
employed as we would like. Further research studies are needed to prove
the usefulness of this information before the insurance carriers will
pay for the testing.
     
We have been performing ductal lavage at the Breast Cancer
Surgery Center for more than five years. Most patients have found it
to be painless, or about the same as having blood drawn. Several
patients are now taking tamoxifen to reduce their risk of developing
breast cancer as a result of the findings obtained from performing
Nipple Aspiration and Ductal Lavage.
     
In the next issue of Women's I, we will discuss one of the
newest treatment innovations improving lives of our cancer survivors.
It is a method of delivering radiation therapy to thebreast tissue in
women who have a partial mastectomy. This technique, termed partial
breast irradiation, causes less damage to normal structures near the
breast. A further benefit is that is completed in 5 rather than 30 days!
See you next issue. As always, you can contact the Breast Cancer
Surgery Center at BreCanSurCen@aol.com.
|